top of page

A Haunting in York’s Treasurer’s House: The Ghostly Roman Legion

Writer: Dr Iain M Lightfoot Dr Iain M Lightfoot
Haunted Intelligently or Residual Energy? The Treasurer's House in York
Treasurer's House, York. (C) National Trust

York, a city steeped in nearly two millennia of history, has no shortage of ghostly tales. Cobbled streets, medieval walls, and centuries-old buildings whisper of those long since passed. Amid these whispered legends stands one of England’s most famous and best-documented supernatural encounters: the Ghostly Roman Legion of the Treasurer’s House. Many believe it to be a true story—one that has fascinated historians and sceptics alike and continues to captivate visitors in search of a genuinely chilling experience.


Incident in the Cellar


The incident allegedly took place in 1953, deep in the cellar of the Treasurer’s House, a grand residence near York Minster. A young plumber’s apprentice named Harry Martindale was tasked with installing a new central heating system. Surrounded by cold stone walls and dim light, Harry climbed a ladder to work on the pipes overhead. All was quiet until he suddenly heard an otherworldly trumpet blast echoing through the cellar.


Peering down, Harry was confronted by the impossible sight of a Roman soldier emerging through the cellar wall, followed by several more, marching two by two. Their armour was worn and their sandals seemed tattered by miles of travel. Most bizarrely, the apparitions appeared only from the knees up,[an important observation] as though their legs were moving beneath a floor that no longer existed. Frozen with fear, Harry watched as the legionnaires passed through the room and vanished into the opposite wall, the final ghostly notes of the trumpet fading into silence.


Post-Encounter Aftermath


Rattled and convinced of what he had witnessed, Harry scrambled down the ladder and fled the cellar. Later, when questioned by the curator of the Treasurer’s House, Harry described every detail of the soldiers’ uniforms, including round shields and short swords. At the time, experts believed Roman legions in Britain had used rectangular shields and distinctive helmets. Yet, upon further research, historians discovered that auxiliary Roman troops stationed around York sometimes used round shields, an obscure fact that Harry, a plumber’s apprentice with little knowledge of ancient Roman warfare, would have not known.


One theory posits that the cellar floor is higher now than it was in Roman times; the soldiers appeared from the knees up because they were walking along an ancient Roman road buried beneath centuries of earth and rubble. Others suggest the entire incident was a vivid hallucination born of a dimly lit cellar and overworked imagination and perhaps gas. Yet, Harry Martindale was adamant about the authenticity of his encounter until his dying day, never profiting from the story or seeking the limelight.


You Can Visit The Cellar


To this day, visitors to the Treasurer’s House can tour the cellar where Harry had his spine-chilling encounter. Staff and guests have reported strange noises, sudden temperature drops, and feelings of being watched. These likely to be spirits other than the Roman Soldiers (see next paragraph). Whether one is a believer in the paranormal or a staunch sceptic, this tale continues to endure. It serves as a reminder that places as old as York can hold centuries of secrets just beneath our feet, waiting for the perfect moment to step through and haunt our modern world.


So What Do We Think Was Going On?


Stone Tape Theory suggests that certain locations and materials can absorb and replay moments of emotional energy, like a kind of paranormal recording. According to this concept, when an emotionally charged event occurs, the atmosphere or surroundings capture the energy in a manner akin to magnetic tape recording. Later, when environmental conditions align just right (such as shifts in temperature, humidity, or electromagnetic fields), the “recording” can be triggered, resulting in a ghostly apparition or residual haunting. Crucially, these manifestations appear to lack interaction with the living, moving on a loop as if caught in the past.


Residual hauntings, viewed through the lens of the Stone Tape Theory, are essentially history stuck on replay. These apparitions don’t seem to be sentient or aware of contemporary observers; instead, they are more like echoes of people and events that once imprinted themselves onto the physical environment. Proponents argue that materials such as stone and wood have the capacity to hold onto these energetic imprints for decades, or even centuries, leading to sightings of ghostly soldiers on battlefields or apparitions wandering ancient corridors. While scientifically unproven, the Stone Tape Theory offers a compelling explanation for why certain places continue to reverberate with traces of the past, inviting the living to witness a spectral glimpse of history playing itself out time and again.


Visit Treasurer’s House: Where History and Mystery Unite


Step back in time at the fascinating Treasurer’s House in York, a historic National Trust property just moments from York Minster. This beautifully preserved town house boasts striking period décor, elegant furniture, and a dazzling collection of fine art that reflects centuries of style. Wander through the grand rooms and tranquil gardens to uncover the captivating stories that have made Treasurer’s House a must-see attraction for visitors from around the world.


Whether you come to admire the architectural splendour, immerse yourself in the layers of York’s rich history, or perhaps catch a glimpse of the paranormal, the Treasurer’s House offers an unforgettable experience. With National Trust’s commitment to preservation, every visit helps protect this iconic property for future generations—so plan your visit today and step into a world where the past truly comes alive.

 
 
 

Comentarios


©2025 by The Ghost Hunting Expert. Southampton.

bottom of page